The Making of Cocoa Caviar

A behind the scenes look with our product development team.

At Polite Society, we’ve never believed bronzer should be just about color. It should flatter the skin, care for it, and feel as effortless as the glow it creates. That belief led us to Cocoa Caviar Bio-Peptide Bronzing Serum: a new kind of bronzing product that blurs the line between skincare and makeup.

Suspended within a silky skincare serum are thousands of bronzed “caviar” pearls that burst as you blend, releasing a natural, sunkissed warmth that looks like it came from the best day of vacation—never glittery, never streaky, never orange.

But formulas like this don’t happen by accident. Behind every bottle is years of testing, problem-solving, and attention to detail. To take you inside the making of Cocoa Caviar, we sat down with Ana Tamayo, our VP of Product Development, to talk about the inspiration + science behind the formula.

 

1. What inspired the creation of Cocoa Caviar? What gap did you see in the bronzer category that this product fills?

AT: Cocoa Caviar was inspired by Jerrod’s love of bronzer and his commitment to skincare. As someone who prefers to stay out of the sun but still loves a naturally bronzed look, he wanted a formula that delivers warmth while supporting a skincare-first philosophy.

We saw a clear gap in the bronzer category. Most focus on color and shimmer, with few combining real skincare benefits and a natural, non-shimmery finish. As a self-proclaimed skincare junkie, Jerrod pushed us to create something that treated skin as beautifully as it enhanced it.

That’s where encapsulation came in—suspending bronzed pigments in a skincare-infused serum base for a smooth, natural bronze without glitter, patchiness, streaking, or orange tones.

2. What were the biggest challenges in developing a bronzing product that also delivers skincare benefits?

AT: One of the biggest challenges was creating a true skincare base that could carry pigment without compromising either skincare benefits or color performance. Many bronzing formulas tend to separate, hence the “shake well” step which can lead to uneven, patchy, or unflattering results if the formula dries too quickly.

Because of this, we focused first on developing a stable, skincare-focused base that feels nourishing and glides smoothly on the skin. From there, the challenge became how to incorporate pigment in a way that blended effortlessly without disrupting the formula. Ultimately, it was about balancing skincare and color so neither compromised the other.

3. Can you explain how the ingredients help improve hydration, elasticity, or overall skin appearance?

AT: Our formula is built on a skincare base, designed to support healthier-looking skin while delivering a natural, believable bronze. We wanted to create a glow that could only come from good skincare, not manufactured from shimmers.

A key hero ingredient is a bio-peptide derived from a cranberry superfruit co-product, known for helping skin appear smoother, more refined, and more radiant by improving the look of texture and tone.

We also included triglycerides which helps lock in hydration while improving glide and preventing patchiness during application.

Finally, cacao extracts bring antioxidant support, helping defend against environmental stressors while promoting a more healthy-looking, energized complexion.

Together, these ingredients don’t just enhance the bronze—they help skin look better underneath it. It adds that extra layer of care in a product you’re reaching for daily.

4. Can it be worn alone, or do you recommend layering it with other complexion products?

AT: The beauty of this formula is that it was designed to fit seamlessly into any step of your skincare or makeup routine. It’s incredibly versatile. Personally, I love wearing it on its own on weekends when I’m running out to yoga or the grocery store. I apply it as the final step in my skincare routine, and it gives just the perfect hint of bronze

During the week, I use it as a primer under makeup, creating a beautiful base with a soft bronzed glow that enhances whatever you layer on top. I also love applying it to the shoulders or legs to help even out the look of my tan. It’s a product that easily adapts to your routine, whether worn alone or layered with other complexion products.

5. How did you engineer the texture so it feels weightless while still delivering pigment?

AT: Achieving that balance required building the formula in layers—starting with texture, then solving for pigment.

We began by developing a lightweight skincare serum base using skin-compatible conditioning agents that allow the formula to glide effortlessly while maintaining hydration and flexibility on the skin. The goal was to create something breathable and comfortable without the heaviness of creams or the dryness of thinner liquids.

These ingredients also play a key role in performance—they help the formula spread evenly, prevent dragging, and ensure the pigment diffuses smoothly rather than clinging to dry areas or texture.

From there, we explored different ways to incorporate pigment, but creating something truly seamless took time. Ultimately, we turned to encapsulation technology to suspend the bronzed pigments within the formula.

Fun Fact: Each bottle contains on average 25,000 caviar pearls, which hold the pigment until the moment you pump and blend the product. As the pearls break, they release the color and mix with the serum base.

6. What detail about the formula are you personally most proud of?

AT: It’s hard to pinpoint just one thing, but what makes me most proud is how well the formula is being received by our Polite Society family. We’re never just creating for ourselves—we’re thinking about you, looking at what people love and where other formulas fall short, and asking how we can make the experience better for your skin.

Developing a product like this feels like solving a puzzle. We take those challenges and ask how we can improve them, with the goal of creating something that enhances both your skin and your makeup routine—not just launching another product.

The most rewarding part is seeing people try it for the first time. Hearing how much they love it and feeling that excitement makes all the challenges along the way completely worth it.

So Cocoa Caviar isn’t just a bronzer—it’s a reimagination of what bronzer can be. Skincare, color, and experience, all in one step. Because at Polite Society, we’re not interested in doing things the usual way, we’re here to make them better. Stay tuned to see what our next big thing will be.

XOXO,

Team Polite Society